Should I Replace My Tub With a Walk-In Shower?
If you never use your bathtub and you’ve caught yourself dreaming about a spa-style walk-in shower, you’re not alone. Walk-in showers are one of the top remodeling trends of 2025, and more homeowners across Lancaster and York are asking:
“Is it smart to remove my tub? Will it hurt resale value?”
Let’s walk through the real pros, cons, and what you should consider before making the switch.
Why Homeowners Are Ditching the Tub
Convenience
Tubs can feel dated and inconvenient — especially as we age or deal with limited mobility. A walk-in shower offers:
Easy access (no high step-over)
Safer bathing with optional grab bars
Roomier feel with glass doors and open layouts
Lifestyle Fit
If you’re not regularly bathing kids or pets, a shower just makes more sense.
Most of our clients say:
“We haven’t used the tub in 10 years — it’s just taking up space.”
Does It Hurt Resale Value?
Here’s the honest truth:
➡️ In a one-bathroom home:
It’s usually best to keep at least one tub. Many buyers still want the option, especially families with young kids.
➡️ In a 2+ bathroom home:
You’re totally safe replacing one tub with a walk-in shower — as long as you still have another tub in the house.
According to Zillow and NAR data:
Homes with a luxury shower upgrade often sell faster
Updated, low-maintenance showers are a big selling point
Buyers love the sleek, modern look of a frameless or solid surface walk-in system
Bonus: A walk-in shower is also a top aging-in-place upgrade, which increases long-term value if you’re planning to stay in your home for years.
What Does a Tub-to-Shower Conversion Cost?
Here’s what we offer at B&M Home Improvement Solutions for full removal and replacement with a solid surface walk-in system:
| Tier | Price Range | What It Includes | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 🔹 Essential Series | $12,000–$14,000 | Shower walls, basic pan, standard fixtures | |
| 🔸 Signature Series | $14,000–$16,000 | Upgraded Shower pan, 12″x 12″ Niche, framed door, trim options, 1 18″ Grab Bar | |
| 🔴 Elite Series | $16,000–$17,500 | Frameless glass, thermostatic Shower valve, multiple grab bars, showroom-selected finishes and MORE! |
All packages include full demo, haul away, and 2–3 day professional install.
What’s the Process Like?
Here’s what happens if you call us for a tub-to-shower conversion:
In-Home or Virtual Consultation – We assess the space, talk through your needs, and give firm pricing.
Visit Our Showroom (Optional) – Choose your panels, niche, glass, fixtures, and layout upgrades.
Scheduled Install (2–3 Days) – Full removal of the tub, install new system, finish & clean up.
Final Walkthrough & Warranty Packet – You’ll know how to clean, what’s covered, and how to use it day one.
Real Talk: Is It Worth It?
If you’re staying in your home:
✅ You’ll love it every single day.
✅ Less time cleaning, more time enjoying.
✅ No awkward tub ledge to step over.
If you’re thinking of selling:
✅ You’ll impress buyers with a modern upgrade
✅ Add value with minimal long-term maintenance
✅ Showcase a custom, finished bathroom — not a tired builder-grade tub
Material Options
We specialize in solid surface systems by Samuel Mueller, which are:
Grout-free and non-porous
Easy to clean
Custom-sized to your space
Fast to install with zero compromise on quality
But we also do high-end custom tile showers for clients who want a luxury look with a little more personalization.
FAQ: Tub-to-Shower Conversions
Q: Will I lose storage space without the tub?
A: No — we build in custom niches or shelving into the new shower. You’ll actually gain accessible storage.
Q: What if I want a bench?
A: We can build in corner shelves or full-length benches depending on layout.
Q: Is it messy?
A: Not with us. We protect your floors, haul everything away, and clean daily.
Let’s See If It’s Right for You
Ready to ditch the tub and make your bathroom work for your lifestyle?
We’ll show you options, walk through pricing, and let you visit our showroom before you commit to anything.
👉 Schedule Your Free Shower Consultation
🛁 No pressure. No mess. Just better bathing.